North American Interviews

Canada - Dave Bleakney

Interview Details

  • PGA Affiliation: Canadian Union of Postal Workers
  • Region: Canada
  • Language: English
  • Interviewee - Dave Bleakney
  • Interviewer - Lesley Wood
  • Date: November 2016, Toronto

Video/Audio

Insert media link here or remove section

Transcript

Interviewer: Alright do you wanna use your name, or not use your name…or do you wanna figure out what you want to use after the task?

Interviewee: Figure out after…

Canada - Lesley Wood

Interview Details

  • PGA Affiliation: Direct Action Network

  • Region: North America

  • Language: English

  • Interviewee: Lesley Wood

  • Interviewer: Leen Amarin

  • Date: May 16 & May 23 2023

  • Bio: Lesley Wood was involved in the Direct Action Network in New York City, participated in the organizing of the PGA North America conference in Amherst, MA in June 2001. She is involved in the Peoples Global Action Oral History project, and currently works in Toronto, Canada.

Canada - Mac Scott

Interview Details

  • PGA Affiliation: Direct Action Network
  • Region: North America
  • Language: English
  • Interviewee: Mac Scott
  • Interviewer: Lesley Wood
  • Date: July 29 2018
  • Bio: Mac Scott is a longtime organizer from Toronto. He was involved in supporting the PGA during his time in Victoria (VPIRG), New York City (Direct Action Network) and in Toronto (No One is Illegal, Ontario Coalition Against Poverty, Movement Defence Committee). He is an immigration consultant in Toronto.

Transcript

Lesley Wood: All right, so this is a PGA interview on July 29th.

Canada - Mostafa Henaway

Interview Details

  • PGA Affiliation: Mobilization for Global Justice Toronto
  • Region: North America - Canada
  • Language: English
  • Interviewee: Mostafa Henaway
  • Interviewer: Lesley Wood
  • Date: December 2016
  • Bio: Mostafa Henaway was involved in York University’s Mobilization for Global Justice Toronto, Canada, and is now based in Montreal.

Transcript

Lesley Wood: So, and… PGA: you know there is a lot of different stuff you can say about it, but why don’t we start with what was your connection to it?

Canada - Sarita Ahooja

Interview Details

  • PGA Affiliation: CLAC
  • Region: North America - Canada | Montreal, Quebec
  • Language: English
  • Interviewee: Sarita Ahooja
  • Interviewer: Lesley Wood
  • Date: November 2016
  • Bio: Sarita Ahooja is a grassroots anti-capitalist organiser from Montreal. She has worked in community-based develpment, human rights, and indigenous sovereignty movements throughout the Americas, as well as in India and Palestine. Some of the orgnisations she has been active in since the early 1990s: Project acompagnement Quebec-Guatemala, EZLN National & International Solidarity Movement, UNAM Student Strike, la CLAC, NOII-Montreal, SAB-SSF, UFCW migrant worker unionization, Montreal neighborhood housing rights groups.

Transcript

Lesley Wood: So, tell me how PGA played out here, and how it translated what people who were doing Zapatista solidarity work to the local context. Can you say something more about that?

United States of America - Brooke Lehman

Interview Details

  • PGA Affiliation: Caravan tour/ Direct Action Network
  • Region: North America - United States
  • Language: English
  • Interviewee: Ann Stafford
  • Interviewer: Lesely Wood (contact person)
  • Date:
  • Bio: Brooke Lehman was an activist in social movements and worked in the East Coast coordination team for the international Caravan sponsored by the Peoples’ Global Action network and part of the Direct Action Network. The attached text is from her in lieu of an interview.

Transcript

Lesley Wood: This is an oral history in review around the role of Peoples’ Global Action (PGA) Network. While no interview was done with Brooke we did recieve this material from her.

United States of America - Mario Galván

Interview Details

  • PGA Affiliation: Zapatista Solidarity Coalition, Sacramento California, US

  • Region: North America

  • Language: English

  • Interviewee: Mario Galván

  • Interviewer: Lesley Wood

  • Date: September 4, 2024

  • Bio: Mario Galván was an active member of the Zapatista Solidarity Coalition, Sacramento California.

Transcript

Lesley: Okay, so this is Lesley talking to Mario Galvan on September 14th, 2024. We’re doing this by zoom. So how did you hear about or get involved in Peoples Global Action? What’s the story?

United States of America Raj Patel

Interview Details

  • PGA Affiliation: Caravan
  • Region: North America - United States | Ithaca, New York
  • Language: English
  • Interviewee: Raj Patel
  • Interviewer: Lesley Wood
  • Date: 21 March 2025
  • Bio: Raj Patel is a Research Professor at the University of Texas At Austin’s LBJ School of Public Affairs, and the author of several books including Stuffed & Starved, and, with Jason W Moore, A History of the World in Seven Cheap Things. He is also the co-chair of the International Panel of Experts on Sustainable Food Systems, and the co-director of the feature documentary, The Ants & The Grasshopper.
  • Transcript:

Transcript

Lesley Wood: How did you hear about PGA? How did you get involved in PGA?

z - Canada - Asociacion de Mujeres Indigenas de Canada

Interview Collection

To gather: This Archive is hoping to receive or collect interviews from various North American organizations.

Overcoming Limitations

This project does not represent the full range of movements and activists involved in PGA. Like so many activist and research projects, this one is shaped by limited social networks and by resource imbalances and priorities within our global system.

If you can help with contacts, interviews, or would like to participate in some other way, please contact us info[@]pgaoralhistory.net. We have interviews from just a few of the following organizations:

z - USA - Direct Action Network

Interview Collection

To gather: This Archive is hoping to receive or collect interviews from various North American organizations.

Overcoming Limitations

This project does not represent the full range of movements and activists involved in PGA. Like so many activist and research projects, this one is shaped by limited social networks and by resource imbalances and priorities within our global system.

If you can help with contacts, interviews, or would like to participate in some other way, please contact us info[@]pgaoralhistory.net. We have interviews from just a few of the following organizations:

z - USA - Tampa Bay Action Group

Interview Collection

To gather: This Archive is hoping to receive or collect interviews from various North American organizations.

Overcoming Limitations

This project does not represent the full range of movements and activists involved in PGA. Like so many activist and research projects, this one is shaped by limited social networks and by resource imbalances and priorities within our global system.

If you can help with contacts, interviews, or would like to participate in some other way, please contact us info[@]pgaoralhistory.net. We have interviews from just a few of the following organizations:

z - USA - Zapatista Solidarity Coalition

Interview Collection

To gather: This Archive is hoping to receive or collect interviews from various North American organizations.

Overcoming Limitations

This project does not represent the full range of movements and activists involved in PGA. Like so many activist and research projects, this one is shaped by limited social networks and by resource imbalances and priorities within our global system.

If you can help with contacts, interviews, or would like to participate in some other way, please contact us info[@]pgaoralhistory.net. We have interviews from just a few of the following organizations:

zz - North America - Various Groups

Interview Collection

To gather: This Archive is hoping to receive or collect interviews from various North American organizations.

Overcoming Limitations

This project does not represent the full range of movements and activists involved in PGA. Like so many activist and research projects, this one is shaped by limited social networks and by resource imbalances and priorities within our global system.

If you can help with contacts, interviews, or would like to participate in some other way, please contact us info[@]pgaoralhistory.net. We have interviews from just a few of the following organizations:

United States of America Raj Patel

Interview Details

  • PGA Affiliation: Caravan
  • Region: North America - United States | Ithaca, New York
  • Language: English
  • Interviewee: Raj Patel
  • Interviewer: Lesley Wood
  • Date: 21 March 2025
  • Bio: Raj Patel is a Research Professor at the University of Texas At Austin’s LBJ School of Public Affairs, and the author of several books including Stuffed & Starved, and, with Jason W Moore, A History of the World in Seven Cheap Things. He is also the co-chair of the International Panel of Experts on Sustainable Food Systems, and the co-director of the feature documentary, The Ants & The Grasshopper.
  • Transcript:

Transcript

Lesley Wood: How did you hear about PGA? How did you get involved in PGA?

Raj Ratel: I’d worked at UNCTAD in Geneva at various points in the 90s. And I was doing my PhD research at the time. So I was based at Cornell, but doing work on how the WTO affects the Global South. And when I was at UNCTAD, I fell in with the secretarial staff who basically have their own sort of circuit of mates within UNCTAD who also had mates at the WTO. I got to know the librarian at the WTO, fantastic man. And he made it clear that it was possible for me to get an internship at the WTO. I think it must have been 98. I managed to finagle my way in waving credentials and sounding posh. Before I left Geneva, I saw that there was a people’s seminar on the WTO. And so I was like, well, this is perfect, because what I’ll do is I’ll work at the WTO by day. And then, hopefully they’ll be interested to hear the insider story. And I didn’t realize that the person who was running it, or one of the people who was associated with it, was Kolya Abramsky.

Raj Ratel: So when I turned up there, Sergio was leading the discussion. Kolya had apparently seen my request to come join, and he was like, “well, you know, we don’t kick anyone out, and as if this idiot from the WTO wants to come and be in the People’s Seminar, we’ll charge him full whack.” And I said “Fine, you know, the university is paying.” So I rocked up there and it turned out that these were the comrades I’d been looking for.

It helped that I went to college with Kolya’s brother. He knew me from left circles there when I was an undergraduate. And so it was like, oh, you know Sasha Abramsky? Yes! I stood next to Sasha when he was dressed as Lenin in college. So it became clear that I was family once removed, and that was the sort of reassurance that folk needed for me to start being a bit more sort of active in the group. Then I pitched in with some of the seminars and I shared what I knew of the workings of the WTO alongside Sergio. Just in a couple of sessions. That was my initiation, as it were, into the circles of PGA.

Lesley: If you were to tell a story to somebody about what the PGA was, what would you say?

Raj Ratel: It was always sort of an experiment. It grew out of the Zapatista-inspired encuentros and solidarity networks but then grew into something that was much more interesting, particularly with its articulations La Via Campesina. In that moment, it started to become complicated because it wasn’t just sort of anarchism all the livelong day. Many, many of the people in Via are not anarchists. With LVC’s entry, they started to become more of a venue for exchange, deep listening, and engagement. And mercifully, it was free of Trots. So that was the other thing that was fantastic about it was the kind of internationalism that the International Socialist Organisation didn’t have its fingers. I found very attractive. One didn’t need to sort of stand on street corners selling papers in order to be connected to some organisation that was internationalist. And there were ways in which local groups could be connected and where there seem to be a ready made infrastructure, which I later came to understand was a lot of Sergio’s effort and a few people really at the center of things, making sure that the flows of communication were smooth. But that’s what I would say. I do think it was an experiment and a loose network rather than an organization with a headquarters. I’m not sure there was one. I mean, I know where a lot of secretarial work happened, but it was it was pretty distributed even back in the day.

Lesley: Yeah. And were there particular moments that stood out for you?

Raj Ratel: I mean, after meeting the comrades there, the first time I met Professor Nanjundaswamy and traveled in India with the PGA for a bit was transformative. I wasn’t quite a fish out of water, but I understood that my place as an activist based in the Global North was really just to be useful and to sort of write things up and listen very closely and then see if there are things that needed doing. If there were, ask if they needed doing, then do them. But there was a moment I remember where we were having a sort of exchange with some movements in Kerala. And it just struck me that there were just no women being advanced in the discussion. So that was a moment where I felt comfortable because my ancestors are South Asian and because I, you know, I was studying patriarchy and sexism in Zimbabwe.

Raj Ratel: I had tools and I had means and opportunity to be able to interrupt a flow of activism with my own voice in a way that felt constructive. I remember that moment in particular where I was invited to speak, and then I spoke about south Asian men’s shared duties of liberation from patriarchy. That felt like solidarity at work in a way, and a way for me to find my own voice.

That felt like a moment where it wasn’t just me learning. I was learning all the damn time in the PGA. You know, it was so exciting to be in seminar rooms with the man who would become the president of Bolivia or, to be around a ton of movement learning, you know, a fire hose of information. But there was a moment where it was like, well, look, here’s a way I can contribute as a comrade. And that felt like a moment where I, I felt my ground, I felt ground beneath my feet in a way that was unusual for me at that time because all of this was so new.

Lesley: Yeah. That’s interesting that there had been enough trust built that you could have that conversation. I mean, if you were to say, you know, what PGA did, well, there’ll be the opposite question in a minute. But like, what do you think it succeeded in doing or what did it do well?

Raj Ratel: Well, you know, every strength is a weakness. So what the PGA did was federate and allow a whole bunch of people to come together with a politics that was clear. I remember, Sergio and Olivier talking about the approaches that they received from the far right who were also against the World Trade Organization. And, we were absolutely clear that they should go fuck themselves. And what irony, now that they’re the ones in charge of ignoring the WTO and dismantling it.

But the reason that we told them to go fuck themselves was precisely because we knew that they would engage in a way that was xenophobic, that would that wasn’t actually about empowering workers so much as fueling a sort of a bourgeois white supremacy and an agenda of racial purity to which we were utterly opposed. So that clarity of politics, and its non-denominational character meant that, you know, we had all kinds of people there. And I loved the way that we were, in PGA spaces. It was very welcoming. I hosted the WTO tour bus when it drove from New York all the way over to Seattle in the run up to the 1999 Ministerial.

Raj Ratel: I lived in a like a communal house. It was huge. We had plenty of space. So everyone on the bus got off and was able to stay a night or two with us. And you know, people were able to give talks and students were able to learn and there was just an engagement with the politics of the moment. There was a real openness and a real capacity to foster curiosity around the people in, at the edges of PGA who could be brought in or could be informed about the politics of what was happening. And I thought the caravan model is both metaphor and action for the way that the PGA articulated things. I like that the individual wagons in the caravan, each having their own kind of capacity to wander off, but nonetheless be in a caravan together. Again, this is a strength and weakness, because that meant that this wasn’t a train with strong bonds between the carriages, with a set direction and a timetable.

Raj Ratel: It was meandering and it was exploratory and it was always about creating the connections that would outlast the caravan itself or outlast the organization itself. I’ve been thinking a lot about the sort of durability of movements. And what legacies of social movements are. And I’m just finishing a paper at the moment about the Italian mondine,1 the women rice workers in northern Italy who were able to kick ass and take names to such an extent that places where they were active later showed greater women’s political participation and were more likely to have a nursery school. I mean, there’s a long durée effect of some of these things, even if the movement peters out And I’ve been thinking about that for the PGA. I mean, it’s not like the bonds that we developed there and the skills that we developed and the ways that we learned of engaging have disappeared. They’ve just been re-articulated, and I think that is precisely the weakness of the articulation between different views within the PGA, which was always its strength, was always its weakness, and that’s fine.

Lesley: Yeah. I was having a conversation. Do you know Stefan Christoff in Montreal? He was involved with CLAC, and he was worrying that we didn’t build enough institutions and that the memory of that particular period that we’re talking about here is gone. And I’m not sure I because I do think, yes, the practices are there, the ideas are there, they evolve. But you know, should we have built something that was durable in a different way?

Raj Ratel: I think the time comes and goes for things like parties, for example. Bear in mind that I felt like the PGA was an explicit and very thoughtful reaction to the failure of Trotskyism. I mean, it’s an anti-party approach and it’s an anti-institutional approach. I think at that time with the fall of the Soviet Union, and the various kinds of fissiparous politics within the ISO, it was a wise move. I accommodated the fact that there were a lot of people who were very interested in socialist politics, but also very interested in anarchist politics and very interested in exploring Indigenous anarchism, which is what it looked like was happening in Chiapas. I think it had to look that way. The party structure, I think is very useful. Some of my comrades now here were in the Black Panther Party in the 60s, right, late 60s, early 70s. That party was smashed almost immediately, but they’re around and they’re now reforming in different ways to fight climate change and reconstruct here in the South. The party structure is necessary sometimes, and it may be that we get inducted into that in some way, soon. But I think in its moment we couldn’t. And, and it was attractive that we didn’t.

Lesley: Yeah. Yeah. I wonder too. And this is like, I’m off script, but whatever, wondering about the particular moment in terms of like early internet that was shaping what was going on and how it would have been different if we were to do it today. Yeah. Yeah.

Raj Ratel: I wonder how possible it would be if we did it today. I mean, the problem is that one of the joys of the PGA process was sitting on your ass in the same room as everyone else. And although, you know, internet 1.0 was useful in getting out proclamations and sort of coordinating a few set things. The fact that you had to actually go to a computer, sit down and check because your phone could only do texts, was a great advantage, I think. I mean, I think it made it possible for us to engage with one another, trust each other, and have each other’s backs and do the kind of clandestine planning sometimes that was useful in some of the actions in 2000 and 2001. It otherwise would have been easily subverted and infiltrated with today’s organising technologies. So, I do think it was of its moment. I wonder how easy it would be to do it again.

Lesley: But, I mean, it’s almost like you need a certain amount of friction in order to make it meaningful and serious. I mean, I think my experience was, was quite different. And because I was really very much based in the US and Canada. We had no contact with the kind of the European situation so much. We were getting stuff through the internet, believing it and doing it. So, you know, nobody speaks for the PGA. We have no resources. And we were you at the conference in, Massachusetts, the like attempt to do a North American one.

Raj Ratel: How was it?

Lesley: I think I made some mistakes. So I was curious about when you were saying you had the collective house with the caravan. Where was that?

Raj Ratel: In Ithaca?

Lesley: In Ithaca. Okay. So then that was before Seattle. That was like, yeah, it was it would have been 2001 in Western Mass. And um, and we were preparing for Cochabamba.

Raj Ratel: Oh that’s right. Yeah.

Lesley: And so we were using this process that was that 50% of the folks who were representing the US and representing Canada were poor. People’s organizations had to be a majority women or a majority of women, people of color, queer folks. We were trying to really live out that, but the people who showed up at the meeting weren’t necessarily representative of that, right? So Canada, because it was the networks are different, was able to actually make that happen. So the delegates who went from Canada to Cochabamba were mostly indigenous groups and poor people’s organizations. But in the States, there was concern that we don’t have the capacity to actually make this happen. And so there was a bit of frustration and squabbling that happened. And I remember David Graeber saying to me, “isn’t it better that just people go who want to go if we can’t actually make it happen?” And I was like, no, we must try. And, you know, in hindsight, I should have been a little less rigid on that, but I think we were trying to fight the critique at that point of the global justice movement as white middle class students where we were like, didn’t want to send white middle class students repping the US to Cochabamba. So I don’t not many people went from the US. I mean, it was also right after 9/11. So it was like things were pretty crazy. So anyway, a very particular experience. But there is something about the timing of, of this experiment that I think is absolutely critical. So you were talking about what was working in terms of this experiment and the kind of pros and cons. What did you find were the frustrations, within the experiment? Or things that it didn’t do as well as it would have liked to. I mean, I know you gave a dialectical answer, but.

Raj Ratel: Well, I think it has to be that. Right? I mean to wish the PGA caravan to instilled revolution in the US might have been unrealistic. I mean, it’d be great, but as you say, 9/11 fucked us so badly. I mean that was a severe setback for the internationalism we were building in this country. Because ever since then, we’ve been on the back foot when trying to recover and recuperate a kind of fluidity of movements in the US, between those that can articulate, you know, Black struggles with African struggles with indigenous struggles. All of that felt so much easier in 99. There was a sort of jouissance. I mean, a sort of playfulness with it that that I really enjoyed, particularly in Seattle. I mean and it was useful to have sort of PGA experience of repression from Prague in Miami, for instance.

Raj Ratel: After 9/11 in particular, concerns about infiltration were legitimate. But in terms of what PGA should have done that it didn’t do, I mean were there enough people of color from the United States? No, obviously. Were there that many representatives from sub-Saharan Africa? Well not really, no. And, you know, I think that omission because of the access and because of the sort of preponderance of Spanish speakers, reflected the ways that race works in the Americas. So, I certainly think that it was it was a more lonely experience for a person of color within that organization than it really should have been. But who’s that on? I mean it’s an organization with its own history and with its own sort of dynamics. So perhaps I’m just being too forgiving of PGA when I still think that given what it was and where it was organizing, it was still pretty fucking good.

Lesley: Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. I mean, its legacy lives on in Toronto in that like, No One is Illegal and the legal support committee the hallmarks still sort of reverberate. Right. And there was this thing called the PGA bloc up until basically around ten years ago, that was a network between Toronto, Montreal and Ottawa that was sort of anarchist, small a anarchist organizing spaces. So, and then like the interviews, although I haven’t translated them, but the interviews in Brazil, the person who coordinated those, they talk about the resonances with the free transit movements and some of the struggles down there. Um, so yeah, it has all these different descendants.

Raj Ratel: You know, I mean, I’m very excited to see the sort of the genealogy that you’re able to trace, the saliva trail if you will.

Lesley:: There’s an image. Yeah. Thanks.

Lesley: What do you think the lessons are for today’s movements?

Raj Ratel: Well, I think that again, understanding that it was it emerged from when it did, means that it would be it would be foolish to wish something like that into existence now. But I do think that with the rise of the far right here and elsewhere, people are looking for ways to build on histories of the past in ways that make sense for right now, given the communications technologies that are around right now.

And I think that the PGA’s insistence on face-to-face contact as a mode of education is something that’s really quite unique. I mean, it was weird back then, and I still think that it was incredibly effective to have not just one person trail through, but just a shit ton of people come into your town and be in community with your community. I think as political education and political theater was it was really unrivaled. And it’s definitely a lesson for today. But the politics that make that possible, I think, have frayed a little bit, certainly in the United States. And again, as I say, we’re trying to recuperate some of that internationalism. Um, but I also think that this moment calls for something else. Um, and insofar as PGA lives, it lives through the skills and through the articulation and through our knowledge of one another.

Raj Ratel: But in an era of catastrophic climate change where a lot of the work that needs to happen now is shot through with the work of social reproduction i.e. PGA wasn’t really there for discussions of social reproduction and survival and reconstruction in the ways that we need some descendant organization to be. So when I’m looking at movements around the world that are doing sort of what the PGA was doing, these organizations that are very grounded in place. One of the things about the PGA was that we were all so footloose, and that, again, strength and weakness. I think that capacity to turn up wherever the protest was, wherever the meeting of the, the IMF was; we mirrored the ambitions of the Washington Consensus to be able to turn up in places, take over a town, make decisions, and fuck off. Now the Washington consensus is dead, and that model of organizing should be too. And that’s fine. But I think now a different kind of model of organizing is necessary, but with the same sort of principles of solidarity, of curiosity, of political education, and of a certain ecumenical approach to politics that embraces anarchism and finds space for the right kind of non-authoritarian socialism. I think that’s definitely a legacy. I am excited to see in some of the places that I work. I mean, do you see it, Lesley?

Lesley: Some days, I mean, right now, obviously there’s so much of an eye on Palestine. Mhm. Um, but that organizing isn’t happening with that same politic that I can see. Not in the same way. I see it more in indigenous led organizing.

Raj Ratel: Yeah.

Lesley: I’m thinking about like the connections between Wet’sewet’en struggles and struggles around various resource extraction projects and mining. Like that’s definitely we have the Prospectors and Developers Association meeting about ten days ago in Toronto. And folks from who are experiencing the horrors of Canadian mining companies around the world come and you see that. I do see it, it feels different. But I don’t know, I, you know, I’m like, maybe I’m just getting old. I’m like a boundless optimist. I’m always looking for the hope. Yeah. because there’s no other way. We’ve got to figure it out. Yeah, yeah.

Raj Ratel: I mean, I certainly drink my hope from outside North America. I mean, it’s one thing to be in a country that is experiencing hegemonic decline and is going through the paroxysms of decline always with a rise in militarism at the apex of finance capitalism. But to go outside and to see what everyone else is doing, you know, watching America sort of swirl around like a turd in the bowl is much more hopeful. It gives you perspective. That’s why the moments of internationalism and solidarity I’ve been able to experience have been really quite moving and engaging.

I put together a meeting, last year, where the MST met the South African shack dwellers movement Abahlali baseMjdondolo, the Southern Peasant Federation of Thailand, an indigenous women’s group from the Philippines, and some of these descendants of the Black Panthers from Houston. We all got together in Bangkok and we were trading stories and ideas around care and the polycrisis. We talked about how to engage with one another, and describing the work that’s already happening in the movements, given catastrophic climate change and the rise of authoritarianism. Abahlali spoke of an activist comrade who’d been assassinated, and it brought out how much of our time was spent offereing mental health care for the comrades who are traumatized by either police violence or by some shitty thing happening in their farm being destroyed or their house being destroyed or their lives being uprooted by flood or fire. And all of a sudden it became clear that a lot of the work to counter the polycrisis is care work in one way or another.

Lesley: Um, yeah.

Raj Ratel: That grounded care work is not what I saw at the PGA. That understanding of what activism is for wasn’t centered on reproductive labor and on care more broadly understood. But the idea that you could get a bunch of people together, and structure a discussion where everyone was equal, everyone was respected, and that there were, you know, the right kinds of dynamics fostered all the way along, that’s something I picked up from the PGA. And so I do think that there’s, as I say, there are ways in which all of this is getting rearticulated.

Lesley: Yeah.

Raj Ratel: So, I am sad that I don’t get to see some of my old comrades as much as I’d like. It’s never great when political organizations unravel. But I was lucky enough to be sufficiently at the edges of it that I wasn’t caught in any of the sort of acrimony that I know other people have been caught up in. Instead, I just get to take the best away from it. And so, I mean, that’s why at some level, this is going to be a fairly superficial interview for you because.. .

… Lesley: What legacies do you see?

Raj Ratel: I mean, you know, Indymedia was a very useful thing for PGA comrades to have incubated and then, you know, and borrowed from. I helped start up Indymedia Zimbabwe after Seattle. And then, you know, in the end, it sort of petered out in part because, who in Zimbabwe has the internet? The folk who I was handing over to in Harare after I was kicked out were from the good tendency of the ISO, but they were still ISO. Then most of them were relocated and or killed by Mugabe. So it all sort of petered out. But I do think that the idea of being able to tell your own story was an innocent and beautiful thing back in the day. I mean at some point, being able to tell your own truth when everyone is shouting at you, is important. O course, now we’re in a very different kind of era where telling your own truth is just entirely the point, or rather the most important thing is the “telling” and the truth kind of drops out.

Raj Ratel: But I do think that the organized idea of being able to write back to power and to be able to break what the mainstream media was reporting, and get word out in ways that were a kind of digital subterfuge. I liked that. And I do think that it was a gift to other movements. When I think about how the Abahlali baseMjondolo in South Africa works, the sort of comms backbone that we started even back in the day was really inspired by the way the PGA worked. The communications work, each its own channels and organized in ways that reach the right audience, all that I learned from the mistakes PGA so that we didn’t have to the same ones. I thought that that was that was very useful.

Lesley: Yeah, that makes sense. Is there somebody do you think that we should talk to in sub-Saharan Africa? Because really, it’s a big hole.

Raj Ratel: Yeah. I do want it on the record that everything Patrick Bond touches turns to shit.

Lesley: I’ve got all my questions, but are there other things I should have asked about?

Raj Ratel: I’m sure I’ll think of half a dozen things as soon as we hang up. I’m really interested in seeing these connections and seeing what the timeline looks like, because, again, my memory is fairly sporadic when it comes. If I were to have the email trail, I think, I think it’d be much easier for me to be able to reconstruct with a lot more authority. So once I see the what the timeline looks like a little bit, I’m almost certain that I will have more interesting things to say. I’m grateful, Lesley, for the work that you’re doing.

Lesley: It’s so much happened in a very short period of time. That’s one of the things that’s striking is that really was just a few years, which gives, you know, gives me hope.

Raj Ratel: Yeah. And just such a handful of people. I mean, that was the other thing I’m trying to, you know, spark hope in my my students. Um, and I point out to them that, you know, the Black Panther Party achieved an extraordinary amount in a short period, with relatively few people, two thousand at its height. You know, those young people just changed the course of this country. It was the party in the right time and the right in the right sort of crisis. I mean, I think, you know, PGA was what it was, but there was not much chance of us being able to effect revolutionary change because, you know, the clock of the world wasn’t set to the right hour. But now, now, I think is much more our time.

Lesley: What are you teaching?

Raj Ratel: I teach a course a semester on food systems.

Raj Ratel: I just helping my students. So it’s a public policy school, so I just do stuff with them on, working to do practical stuff around the world food system. Policies, either for municipal municipalities or countries or at the international level.

Lesley: We’re lucky. We’re lucky ones. Listen, thank you so much. Let’s keep the conversation going.

Raj Ratel: Okay. Thanks a lot. Take care. Bye.